1. The short answer: earlier than you think
Most landlords start too late. They wait until the lease is about to expire, then rush to instruct surveyors, inspect the property, and prepare a schedule under time pressure. Whilst the intention may be to enforce a cash settlement in lieu of the required works, this approach can produce weaker claims and worse outcomes.
The ideal starting point is 12-18 months before lease expiry.
This gives you time to:
- Review the lease thoroughly (and any connected documents)
- Inspect the property properly
- Prepare a comprehensive, well-evidenced schedule
- Serve it with time for meaningful negotiation
- Signal to your tenant that you’re taking this seriously
Starting the process early assists you in minimising your void period.
2. The 12-18 month window: what to do
Months 18-12 before expiry: Strategic planning
- Review the lease — Understand exactly what your tenant is obligated to do. Check for any Schedule of Condition that might limit claims.
- Review ancillary documents — Licences for alterations, side letters, any variations.
- Initial inspection — Get a sense of the property’s condition and likely claim size.
- Instruct your surveyor — Brief them on the property, the lease, and your objectives.
Months 12-6 before expiry: Preparation
- Detailed inspection — Your surveyor inspects thoroughly, documenting every breach.
- Schedule preparation — Formal Schedule of Dilapidations prepared to Protocol standards.
- Cost quantification — Each item properly costed with supporting evidence.
- Quality check — Review the schedule before service. Is everything properly referenced? Are costs defensible?
Months 6-0 before expiry: Service and negotiation
- Serve the schedule — Ideally 6 months before lease end, giving time for response and negotiation or adequate time for the tenant to complete the works.
- Tenant response — They have 56 days under the Protocol to respond with their position.
- Negotiation — Work through the Scott Schedule process toward settlement.
- Resolution — Most claims started this early settle around or shortly after lease expiry.
3. Why early engagement matters
Stronger schedules
Rushed schedules contain errors, miss items, and include weak claims. A schedule prepared without time pressure is more comprehensive and harder to challenge.
Better evidence
Photographs taken 12 months before lease end show the trajectory of deterioration. Multiple inspections build a clearer picture than a single rushed visit.
Negotiating leverage
A tenant who receives a professional schedule well before lease end knows you’re serious. They may even carry out some works, reducing the eventual claim but also the eventual dispute. This will put your property in a more lettable condition.
Time for proper valuation
If Section 18 (diminution) arguments are likely, you need valuation evidence. This takes time to commission and prepare properly.
Avoiding the post-expiry scramble
The Protocol recommends serving claims within 56 days of lease expiry. If you haven’t started preparation until the lease ends, you’re immediately behind schedule. You may also lose the right to claim for reinstatement items depending on the wording of the lease.
4. What happens if you start too late
Rushed preparation
Your surveyor has to inspect, prepare, and serve under pressure. Quality suffers. Items get missed or inadequately evidenced.
Weaker negotiating position
A schedule served months after lease expiry looks reactive, not professional. The tenant’s surveyor will exploit any weaknesses. Some elements of loss may no longer be recoverable.
Protocol concerns
Late service doesn’t invalidate your claim, but it undermines your position if matters proceed to court. Judges consider Protocol compliance.
Lost evidence
The property may be re-let or altered before you’ve documented its condition. Evidence of your tenant’s breaches disappears.
Compressed negotiation
Instead of months to work through issues, you’re trying to settle quickly. Pressure rarely favours the party who created it.
5. Special situations
Break clauses
If your tenant might exercise a break clause, prepare as if the break date is the expiry date. You don’t want to be caught out if they break early.
Tenant not vacating
If lease renewal negotiations are ongoing, prepare anyway. The claim exists regardless of whether the tenant stays. Having it ready strengthens your renewal negotiation.
Multiple properties
For portfolio landlords with multiple lease expiries, plan across the portfolio. Stagger preparation to manage surveyor capacity and your own time.
Problem tenants
If you already know the tenant is difficult or the property is in poor condition, start even earlier. Complex claims need more preparation time.
6. Interim schedules and repairs notices : mid-lease options
If your tenant is causing ongoing damage through failure to maintain, you don’t have to wait for lease expiry. An Interim Schedule of Dilapidations can be served during the lease term.
Interim schedules are appropriate when:
- Ongoing breaches are causing deterioration that shouldn’t wait
- You want to document the position and put the tenant on notice
- The situation is serious enough to warrant formal action and you are prepared to risk forfeiting the lease
An interim schedule isn’t a substitute for a terminal claim — you’ll still serve a full schedule at lease end. But it can prompt action and create a paper trail.
Repairs notices are appropriate when:
-The lease clauses allow for the landlord to re-enter the property to remedy tenant’s breaches.
-You do not wish to risk forfeiting the lease, but need the breaches remedied.
7. The cost of waiting
Consider a property where the eventual dilapidations settlement might be £100,000:
Well-prepared claim (started 18 months early):
- Comprehensive schedule, properly evidenced
- Strong negotiating position
- Settlement: £85,000-95,000 of the valid claim
Rushed claim (started at lease expiry):
- Gaps in evidence, some weak items
- Defensive negotiating position
- Settlement: £60,000-70,000 due to successful challenges
The difference — potentially £20,000-30,000 — far exceeds the cost of early preparation.
8. Practical steps to start now
If your tenant’s lease is ending in the next 18 months:
- Diary the dates — Lease expiry, any break dates, key milestones
- Gather documents — Lease, licences, any Schedule of Condition, previous correspondence
- Instruct a surveyor — Get professional advice on timing and approach
- Initial inspection — Understand what you’re dealing with
- Plan the programme — Work backwards from lease expiry to set preparation milestones
Key Takeaways
- Start 12-18 months before lease expiry — not at or after expiry
- Early preparation produces stronger claims — better evidence, fewer gaps
- The Protocol recommends service within 56 days of expiry — you need to be ready
- Rushed claims settle for less — the cost of waiting exceeds the cost of preparation
- Consider interim schedules and repairs notices — for serious mid-lease breaches
- Plan across your portfolio — if you have multiple expiries coming
Need Help?
If you have a lease expiring in the next 18 months and want to ensure you’re properly prepared, we can help. Early engagement leads to better outcomes.
Related Services:
- Dilapidations for Landlords — Full claim preparation and negotiation
- Interim Schedules for Landlords — Mid-lease schedules for ongoing breaches
- Schedules of Condition for Landlords — Protecting your position at lease start
Related Articles: